In Touch

In Touch 11/19/26

Connor Libis with the Aberdeen Catholic School system joins us to talk about everything going on at Roncalli this month…

In Touch 11/18/26

Grace Chipman from the Aberdeen Area Arts Council joins us to talk about this weekend’s “Winterfest”…

SD News Watch – Mitchell baseball player appeals defamation case to state Supreme Court

(Molly Wetsch – South Dakota News Watch) Months after a judge ruled in favor of the American Legion and two media companies in a defamation lawsuit, former Mitchell baseball player Peyton Mandel is now appealing that decision to the South Dakota Supreme Court, court filings show.

Nexstar Media Group, which owns KELO-TV, and Forum Communications, which owns the Mitchell Republic, were the other defendants in the case prompted by a sentence in a letter from a representative of the American Legion sent to members of the Mitchell Baseball Association.

In November 2024, American Legion adjutant C.P. Van Delist sent the letter to members of the Mitchell Baseball Association saying that Mitchell Baseball would be immediately barred from participating in the American Legion after a rape case involving six players made its way through court.

In July 2025, Peyton Mandel, one of the six players involved in the case, filed a civil lawsuit saying that Van Delist made “false, malicious, and defamatory” statements about him, which were then republished by the Mitchell Republic and KELO.

Van Delist’s letter named all six players involved in the case and said, “All of these individuals are guilty of accessory to a felony, acknowledging by affirmation of their guilty pleas, that the felonies they were charged with, rape and aiding and abetting, did take place.”

Mandel was a player for the Mitchell Baseball team and one of six involved in a hazing incident that took place in 2023 at a Rapid City hotel room. The event, in which another player said the boys held him down and performed forcible digital anal penetration on him, was later characterized as a rape case. He pleaded guilty in 2024 to one count of accessory to a felony as part of a plea deal.

History of the case

Mandel’s argument in the defamation case largely centered around the fact that he did not plead guilty to rape, and that characterizing him as a rapist was incorrect.

Circuit Judge David Knoff heard the defamation case in May and in August granted a motion of summary judgement to Forum Communications and Luke Hagen, editor of the Mitchell Republic, saying that Mandel’s case relied on a “vague admission and the argument that he technically did not admit in court to an accessory to rape or aiding and abetting rape.”

In October, Knoff granted summary judgment to all of the defendants, effectively closing the case.

Appeal documents were filed Nov. 2 and noted as received by the Supreme Court Nov. 18. The process of appealing a court decision can take months and requires both parties’ attorneys to submit briefs on the case.

The case is currently listed as “not ready for hearing” in the docket. When a case is determined ready for hearing – after both parties submit the required briefs to the court – the case will then be put on the court’s calendar.

The South Dakota Supreme Court decides appeal cases in two ways: Either by hearing 15 minutes of oral arguments from each party’s attorneys, with no trial or testimony from witnesses, or by simply reviewing the trial record of the lower court and briefs submitted by the attorneys.

Other lawsuits filed by player allege malicious prosecution, civil rights violations

Mandel and his attorney, Tucker Volesky, have also opened two other civil lawsuits related to the original case in recent months.

In August, he filed a lawsuit against Pennington County States’ Attorney Lara Roetzel, Nexstar and NewsNation host Chris Cuomo. In that case, he alleges that Roetzel’s prosecution was “malicious” and said she conducted a “prejudicial publicity campaign” against the six players involved. The lawsuit cites Roetzel’s appearance on multiple news programs, including NewsNation, as part of that “campaign.”

Then, Mandel filed a lawsuit in September against Nexstar and five Keloland reporters, alleging defamation over articles and television broadcasts published by the outlet. That case centers around statements said and written by reporters after the initial trial in 2024, which Mandel says “portrayed him not merely as a person charged in a criminal case or who pleaded guilty to accessory to a crime without admitting any sexual conduct” but as a “direct perpetrator of rape against a minor.”

Both cases are still pending.

Attorneys involved in the appeal did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Share:

More

In Touch 11/19/26

Connor Libis with the Aberdeen Catholic School system joins us to talk about everything going on at Roncalli this month…

Privacy Policy